Is there religion in your public school? You likely think
not, if you subscribe to the common understanding that religion is “the service
or worship of God or the supernatural” (Merriam-Webster’s Collegiate Dictionary
(MWCD)). Such religion is being systematically removed from public educational
institutions. But I think we need to take another look at the term, “religion.”
There is a broader definition of religion in MWCD. A
religious person is one who “manifests faithful devotion to an acknowledged
ultimate reality or deity.” For the theist ultimate reality is a deity, God,
the Creator and Sustainer of all things. No one disagrees that such a person is
a religious. But the atheist possesses an ultimate reality too, something or
someone other than God. The atheist is equally devoted to the belief that there
is no God as the theist is to the belief that there is a God. Equal devotion implies
equal religion. Both theist and atheist are religious.
At this point most atheists will pull out their trump card—science.
Believe it or not, as a theist I am quite all right with that, as long as the
atheist will acknowledge and abide by the limits of science. What is science? Science
refers to a system of acquiring knowledge. This system uses observation and
experimentation to describe and explain natural phenomena. From this definition
it is easy to understand why theists were the first scientists. An orderly God
would create an orderly world. For the good of people and to increase their
understanding of the Creator, scientists set about to discover and codify that
order. However, because human beings are finite in their ability to observe and
know, science is inadequate as a way to discover ultimate reality. To use
science in this way is to twist science into a religion called scientism.
Is there religion in your school? Yes, there has to be.
Human beings require an ultimate reality to give definition to their lives. But
since they are finite in their ability to know, they must fill in the gap
between limited knowledge and full devotion with faith. That’s why human beings
are inherently religious. All humans possess a faith to fill in the gaps between
what they know and what they believe. That’s true for theists and atheists
alike. There is religion in your school whether your school is private, public, or
parochial.
The First Amendment of the Constitution states that “Congress shall make
no law respecting the establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free
exercise thereof.” To systematically remove by law any mention of a theistic
religion in public schools is to establish the religion of atheism within their
walls. That is unconstitutional. The more appropriate way to approach this is
to create an atmosphere of civility where all religions can be expressed and
even debated. In my opinion such expression and debate should be encouraged
even in so-called Christian schools. In such an atmosphere reason will apprehend
the truth. Jesus said, “The truth will set you free.” Even atheists can agree
with that.

3 comments:
Excellent post, Tom, and nail-head-hitting. By excluding theism, "the State" is establishing "atheism" as the religion of the schoolyard. Better to have open discussion of ALL codified beliefs, than to ban any one or several in favor of another.
The actual wording [often misattributed] of the First Amendment is "...make no law regarding AN establishment of religion..." which has often made me ask if the government is even permitted to require a church [an establishment of religion] to follow any law at all. Probably picky semantics, this.
Galen, semantics do matter, a lot! They did in the writing of the Constitution and they matter in the quoting and interpretation of it. I am actually trying to foment a grassroots, populist movement of thoughtful Constitutionalism through writing and speaking. I need and appreciate all the help I can get in fine tuning my words. Thank you!
Very well stated. Thought provoking.
Post a Comment